Meta ads not working? Check this before you give up

Before you decide Facebook and Instagram ads aren’t for you, check your tracking, your creative and your follow-up. Here’s what a performance media strategist looks at first.

The Big Idea

On episode 16 of The Visual Marketing Podcast, Wasting Thousands on Ads? The Problem Is Not Where You Think, I caught up with Amelia Stanojević, founder of Sparks Fly Social Strategy in Sydney. Amelia and I went to high school together, and somehow we’ve both ended up in marketing. She has more than a decade of experience in sales and performance media, including roles at Yahoo and BuzzFeed, and she started her own business because she felt small businesses were missing out on the insights big brands get.

She’s hearing the same story almost every week right now. A business owner sets up their own Meta ads, often with AI writing the ads, spends a thousand or two thousand dollars, and decides Meta isn’t for them.

When she audits those accounts, the problem usually isn’t the platform. It’s what’s underneath. The tracking isn’t connected, the wrong Instagram account is linked, or the ads themselves are cut off. She even tested Meta’s own AI ad generator, and some of the ads came out as blank squares.

Without that setup working, nobody sees the creative you’ve paid for, and you don’t know who liked it.

“Pretend you’re a customer, go to your own ad, click on your ad... and find the friction.”

Try This Week: be your own customer

Amelia’s one piece of homework from the episode: check your tracking. She’d have every business do this at least once a month.

  • Click your own ad. Do it on your phone, the way a customer would see it.
  • Go all the way through. Landing page, form or cart, checkout. Write down anything slow, confusing or broken.
  • Check your connections. Is your Meta pixel in place, and are the right Facebook page and Instagram account linked? Amelia says most of the time she finds something the business wasn’t aware of, or hadn’t checked in six months.
  • Time your follow-up. Fill in your own enquiry form and see how long it takes to hear back. If someone fills in a form on Monday and gets a call on Wednesday, they may have forgotten they filled it in, or signed up with someone else.

If you’re running ads yourself, Amelia’s advice is to get someone to set up your account and tracking from day one, even if you do the rest yourself. That setup is what powers everything else.

How small businesses can still beat the big brands

Ads cost more than they used to, and Amelia is hearing that from her clients too. But small businesses have something the big brands don’t. They can move fast and have fun with it, without rounds of approvals with 20 people at the table.

  • Invest in your hero content. High quality photography and video, even if it’s once a quarter, then fill the gaps with ad hoc, behind the scenes content. People need to see what you sell, what it does and how it looks, up close and clearly.
  • Earn the scroll stop. A bold hook in the first three seconds, a strong thumbnail and bright colours in the feed.
  • Use video. Amelia says it’s very hard to run a successful campaign without it. For one client, adding a video testimonial dropped their cost per lead by 50% in three days.
  • Run from what you dislike. We had a good laugh about AI poster after AI poster with a paint swipe under the title. Her advice: think about what you dislike most, and go in the opposite direction.

And if being on video makes you cringe, you’re not alone. Amelia says that feeling is biological, because we’re not used to seeing ourselves on camera. Treat your first few takes like the first pancake. Throw them out and keep going.

What’s Moving: AI is moving onto your Google listing

Google has started showing an "AI Overview" at the top of some local business panels, the box that appears when someone searches for a business by name. It’s built from your Google Business Profile and what’s said about you online, and a "Show more" button opens a chat where people can ask follow-up questions about you. It’s showing for some users rather than everyone so far.

What that means for you: the AI can only summarise what it can find. Keep your profile complete and current (hours, services, photos, description), reply to your reviews, and post updates. Those are the raw ingredients it’s working with.

Elizabeth Slade, founder of C i Marketing

Ask Elizabeth

Can I just ask AI to come up with my ads and posts?

You can, but AI doesn’t know you, your business, your personality, your goals or your strategy unless you give it that. Used properly, it’s a great help. Most people just aren’t using it that way yet.

Before you open it, get out of your own head and into your customer’s. Imagine you’re buying your own product or service. How do you want to be treated, and what would you need to trust the business enough to buy? Start there, then let AI help you shape it.

Sources: The Visual Marketing Podcast, episode 16 · Search Engine Roundtable, "Google Local Knowledge Panel As An AI Overview", 17 September 2026

Want a second set of eyes on your ads?

We set up and run Google and Meta ads for New Zealand businesses, starting with the setup and tracking that everything else depends on.

See how we run ads

Get Seen every Thursday

One useful marketing idea, a podcast pick and what’s changing, from Elizabeth and the team. Every Thursday morning.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time.

Elizabeth Slade

Founder of C i Marketing and host of The Visual Marketing Podcast.